Facebook
X
Pinterest
Copy Link
Pasatiempo has long been one of the most distinctive and tightly held neighborhoods in Santa Cruz County. With its historic architecture, oak studded landscape, and world-class golf course setting, it behaves less like a typical neighborhood and more like a private market of its own. Using MLS sales data dating back to the late 1990s, here’s how Pasatiempo real estate has evolved—and what homeowners and buyers should realistically expect heading into 2026.
A Long-Term Perspective: Nearly Three Decades of Appreciation
Looking at closed sales since 1998, Pasatiempo tells a clear long-term story. In 1998, the median sale price in Pasatiempo was approximately $499,000. By 2025, the median sale price had risen to roughly $2.3 million. That represents more than a four-and-a-half-times increase over 27 years, translating to about 5–6% annualized median appreciation, not including the impact of renovations and expansions many homes have undergone. This long-term consistency is one of Pasatiempo’s defining characteristics. Even during broader market cycles, values here tend to move with more restraint on the downside and more conviction on the upside.
Recent Market Phases: From Surge to Normalization
2016–2019: A Step Up – Between 2016 and 2019, Pasatiempo saw steady growth, followed by a notable pricing step-up in 2019. Buyer demand from Silicon Valley, early shifts toward flexible work, and long-term Santa Cruz locals all converged during this period.
2020: Volatility – Like many markets, 2020 showed irregularity due to COVID-19. Median pricing dipped, largely due to a smaller number of sales and a different mix of homes rather than a true decline in underlying value.
2021–2022: Peak Conditions – The most aggressive period in recent history occurred in 2021 and 2022: Median prices peaked near $2.85 million in 2022. Median days on market fell into the single digits and homes frequently sold at or above list price. This was an exceptionally competitive environment fueled by low interest rates, strong equity positions, and lifestyle-driven demand.
2023–2025: Normalization and Balance – Since 2023, the market has shifted into a more balanced phase: Median prices settled back into the low-to-mid $2 millions. Days on market increased, with 2025 averaging closer to two months. Sale-to-list price ratios normalized around 96%. This is not a sign of weakness—it’s a return to a market where pricing accuracy, condition, and presentation matter more.
Sales Volume: A Low-Turnover Neighborhood
Pasatiempo is inherently low volume. In many years, fewer than a dozen homes change hands, which naturally limits price volatility and amplifies competition when quality inventory becomes available. Over the past five years, sales have averaged about 10 homes per year. That limited turnover is a key reason prices remain resilient: supply is naturally constrained, and many homeowners hold for the long term.
The 2026 Outlook: What to Expect
While no forecast is exact—especially in a small, luxury submarket—current trends support a fairly clear range of expectations.
Projected Sales Volume: Approximately 9–12 sales in 2026 This aligns closely with recent historical averages.
Projected Pricing: Using 2025 as a baseline:
- Base case median: ~$2.35M–$2.5M
- Downside scenario: ~$2.2M–$2.35M (rate pressure or broader economic uncertainty)
- Upside scenario: ~$2.5M–$2.7M (rate relief and strong turnkey inventory)
The defining theme for 2026 is likely to be quality-driven performance. Well-located, well-updated, and correctly priced homes should continue to command strong results. Homes with deferred maintenance or aggressive pricing will require more strategy and patience.
What This Means for Homeowners and Buyers
For homeowners, Pasatiempo continues to reward long-term ownership and thoughtful improvements. Pricing and marketing strategy matter more now than it did during the peak years, but demand remains deep for the right product.
For buyers, today’s market offers something that was largely absent in 2021 and 2022: time and leverage. Due diligence, negotiation, and selectivity are once again part of the process.
Final Thoughts
Pasatiempo is not immune to broader economic forces—but history shows it absorbs them differently. Limited inventory, strong buyer demographics, and enduring appeal continue to support long-term value. If you’d like a more detailed breakdown of Pasatiempo trends—or want to understand how your specific property fits into today’s market—I’m always happy to share a data-driven perspective tailored to your situation.
